Cinema

Seconds

1966. Dir.: John Frankenheimer; with Rock Hudson, John Randolph, Frances Reid, Salome Jens. 110 mins.

I saw Seconds (1966) a few evenings ago. Someone recommended it highly, and I was trying to think if I hadn't already seen it at some point. How could I have missed it? And if I had seen it, how come it made no huge impression on me? Having watched the movie, I can say that bits of it do seem familiar, but it has some aggressively unmemorable features that can cause an erasure through boredom in the viewer's mind.

John Randolph, a typical unhappy businessman who, at times, has a camera attached to his back, is accosted at the station by someone who gives him a scrap of paper with an address on it. Goes home, wife, gets anonymous call, “How would you like to start your life over except in Rock Hudson's body?” He goes to the strange organization, waffles, gets remade, etc. His new life commences. That's very interesting. And then ... Now played by Rock Hudson, he meets an awful woman on the beach, who encourages him to seize life, and then takes him to an actual neighbourhood Bacchanalia. He dives into this new life with alacrity. But then he hosts one of those parties they used to have in movies of the period: lots of strangers standing around drinking martinis with an unobtrusive (and, in this case, invisible) jazz trio in the background. He gets drunk, becomes unhappy with his new life. And so on. Rod Serling frowns and looks on in faux disappointment, but actually licking his chops.

The theme is very interesting, and both the look of the movie and its pace are above reproach. There are plenty of things to admire. But it is strangely uneven. There are parts that don't work at all. There are bits missing. And there are lost opportunities in sequences that ought to have talked about the story but instead contain nothing but tat.

Parts even struck me as a rush job. There's a startling continuity error where Rock Hudson is given a pillow on the airplane: we see Hudson put the pillow behind his head, we see the hostess smiling at him, and then we turn back to Hudson to find he obviously has no pillow. I quite thought for a moment that this was to herald some kind of mental confusion sequence, but no. It's just a mistake, and a glaring one. Normally that's no big deal, but here it underscores the host of things neglected by the director: what's going on in this man's mind? What happens when you start a new life? What would the sensation be like? Do things look different? The same? How would you feel about that? Do you still like your coffee with two sugars? What? There are all manner of things that ought to happen but don't.

Contrast that with the good dialogue scenes between John Randolph and the owner of the company, or between Hudson and Frances Reid, his former wife. Not only well composed but even daring, trusting the actor's ability to keep the audience transfixed for long seconds with his tormented silence.

Here, as well as I can recall, is the owner of the life-replacement establishment quizzing Randolph on his possible reasons for remaining in his current life, asking if there is anything of value left for him:

“Anything?”

“ ... I have my boat in the summmer ... I ... ... friends!! ...”

“... Anything at all?”

I think all the acting is remarkable, and John Frankenheimer’s work with his actors is the outstanding achievement of this film.

Il Tempo si è fermato

1959. Dir.: Ermanno Olmi; with Roberto Seveso, Paolo Guadrubbi. 83 min.

The curious thing about this spare and, at times, humorous movie is that it followed hard on the heels of those works by Ermanno Olmi which were purely industrial studies: Cavo ad Olio Fluido a 220.000 Volt, (220,000 Volt Fluid Oil Cable), Fertilizzanti Prodotti dalla Società del Gruppo Edison, (Edison Group Fertilising Products), and Natura e Chimica (Nature and Chemistry), for example, which all appeared in the same year.

Tempo
“...were purely industrial stuides.”

But here, in the minimalist story of a young worker learning the ropes from his senior at a remote hydroelectric station, it is as if man, the putative master of his works, finally makes an appearance in their midst and is set up for some sort of confrontation. At first there is quite a lot of the usual roommate-coworker friction, as the older man gapes in disbelief at the other's mollycoddled outlook and incomprehensibly casual approach to the work. But the man-nature confrontation soon comes in the form of a heavy snow storm, and the two put aside their differences and learn to work together. What at first seems to be the age old insoluble problem of personal space and generational discord is shown to be nothing in the face of several hundred thousand cubic feet of snow.

Strangers on a Train

1951. Dir.: Alfred Hitchcock; with Farley Granger, Robert Walker, Ruth Roman, Leo G. Carroll, Patricia Hitchcock. 101 min.

What strikes me most about Strangers on a Train is the clash of wills, and I think this is the characteristic thing abut Hitchcock's movies, which is often misidentified as suspense. In fact the suspense is merely something that derives from what we know to be the will of the protagonist and its fateful clash with some other's unknown will, or with uncontrollable events.

...a time bomb is shown to be hidden in a parcel...

Hitchcock talked about an early movie of his, in which a time bomb is shown to be hidden in a parcel on a crowded bus. One of the passengers is a small boy. The excitement was to be the viewer's fretting about whether the innocents aboard the bus would be blown up. We see the parcel, we see the passengers. Then—and Hitchcock regarded this as his big mistake—the bomb went off! It was a mistake because the thing that looked about to happen went ahead and happened, so the principle effect is dread followed by shock, but that means that there was no real conflict. Something bad was very likely to happen. It did, predictably. For suspense, however, there has to be a mystery: what will happen? What on earth is going to happen? And why is this happening? To me, of all people? The mystery is what makes for suspense, as in The Birds, where there seems to be no explanation at all, neither for the attacks nor for the periods of calm. We know the main characters want to not get pecked to death, but what on earth do these birds want?

And so in Strangers Farley Granger meets a man with bizarre theories about the perfect murder: if the person who carried out the murder were a complete stranger to the victim, it would be a seemingly motiveless crime and very difficult to understand. Naturally two people could agree to murder each other's victim and, if they were careful to remain strangers in every other way, their crime would be a mystery. This man, Bruno (played by Robert Walker), is almost saying that there would be no crime, in the sense that to outsiders it would only be two motiveless, inexplicable killings.

Of course the hero dismisses all this as so much talk, but soon he finds that Bruno has gone ahead with his part of their non-existent deal. Here again it is a conflict of will. The hero would like his ex-wife to go away, but he can't begin to conceive of someone actually committing a murder. Bruno, for his part, can't see what objection there could be. Not to commit the murders would be just plain silly, when it can be done so easily and they stand to gain so much.

The word "strangers" also means that the two live in different worlds, and Bruno's world is unknowable and horrifying. In the opening of the movie we see only the feet of the two men. Why is that? I think it shows what people can know of each other when they meet. They see only a part of them. When you watch the opening you become curious: who are these people? How come I can only see their shoes? What's the rest of them like? If I could see their faces, I would have some idea of who they are.

In life everything you know of another person amounts to little more than what kind of shoes they wear.

About the Viewer

If an insect were to sit down and watch a movie—okay, that couldn't happen, but suppose he were immobilized and somehow made to sit in front of the screen and watch. Bear in mind that the average movie would take up years of an insect's life, and his mind would be wandering after the first ten seconds or so. In any case, what he might see would not be a movie, but an agonizingly slow series of tableaux.

“The first twenty-four frames would already be pretty taxing...”

The first twenty-four frames would already be pretty taxing, an unthinkable demand on one's attention, but the overall effect would be incomprehensible. For an insect, the experience would be like spending several years touring a colossal art gallery full of almost identical paintings.

You would of course note the tiny difference between the pictures, and maybe experience a temporary relief at any cut that brought with it an entirely different angle or even view, but this too would pall fairly quickly. You would likely soon reach a state of white-hot exasperation: what is this insane nonsense? Why is this happening? Who thought this would be an entertainment?

Those are questions that the conventional non-insect viewer has to ask also.

L'Année dernière à Marienbad

1961. Dir.: Alain Resnais; with Delphine Seyrig, Giorgio Albertazzi, Sacha Pitoëff. 94 min.

This egregiously ... wonderful, awful movie. I must have seen it three or four times before I realized I had no idea what it was about. It was only about the fifth time that I was quite certain of that. Somewhere in the late '90s I managed to make sense of part of it, a ... no, wrong.

I think I first saw something about it in a book about European 20th century culture. Exactly! This is exactly what the words “European 20th century culture” seemed to mean.

Maybe it helps to watch the movie as a graphic process and not concern oneself too much with the subject. In one view, there isn't really an argument: the narrative is more a single event shown as it were in cross-section. A person confronts another person and wants to start (or renew, which here comes to the same thing) a relationship. There is neither a beginning nor an ending there.

This might also put to rest the idea that Robbe-Grillet borrowed heavily from Adolfo Bioy Casares' La invención de Morel. Not only is there not a desert island or any sinister machinery, there is also no plot unfolding itself wearily all over the place.

•

Herbie, everyone's favorite “love bug,” demonstrates his special brand of “car-isma” and high-octane humor in this action-packed, stunt-filled comedy outing. The fun begins when Herbie sets sail for Rio de Janeiro's Grande Premio racing competition with his two new owners.

—Winston Churchill, A History of the English-Speaking Peoples.

•

Deux inspecteurs de police (!) recherchent un criminel voleur et violeur, surnommé Aspirin Kid, parce qu'avant de commettre son forfait, il agit toujours de cette façon : sous le prétexte d'un remboursement d'argent, il pénètre dans l'appartement d'une femme seule, lui demande l'autorisation de téléphoner puis lui réclame de l'aspirine pour calmer une soi-disant migraine passagère.

—Clémenceau, Discours de Guerre.